Plan to scare Josh worked

Katelyn Ciaccio, 22, successfully scared her little brother, Josh Ciaccio, 13, tonight with the help of her other brother, Sean Ciaccio, 21.

"Everything went according to plan," Katelyn Ciaccio said, "and Josh's reaction was even better than what I had hoped for."

After seeing Katelyn Ciaccio walk toward him in an alien costume in their basement, Josh Ciaccio screamed, "Oh my freaking God!" and then ran up the stairs as fast as he could, Sean Ciaccio said.

Katelyn and Sean Ciaccio were laughing for several minutes after the scare occurred, which made Josh Ciaccio a little angry, but he said he "would probably be laughing too" if had been the one to scare one of them.

All three of the siblings expressed regret for not recording the scare on camera.  "We could have sent it in to Tosh.0," Sean Ciaccio said, "it would have been perfect for that show."

Katelyn Ciaccio said that next time she would remember to set up a camera, "just in case the scare turns out as hilarious as this one did."

"This scare definitely makes it into our top three scares of all time," Sean Ciaccio said.